It's fair to say that there are just two mainstream
categories for printers: ink jet and laser. Having said that, how-ever,
we should also point out that this is a bit oversimplified. The laser
printer category also includes nonlaser technologies and printers
combined with scanners and possibly fax machines, known as multifunction
(or all-in-one) printers.There are several
other types of printers available, such as thermal dye printers (for
printing photographs) and thermal printers (for creating mailing
labels). But these are niche printer technologies. Our focus here is on
printers designed for mainstream users.
Ink Jet Printers
Ink jet printers fall into three categories: three-color, four-color,
and photo ink jets. The standard for ink jets is the four-color printer.
The typical model holds two cartridges—one with black ink and one with
color inks (cyan, magenta, and yellow). Some hold four cartridges, with
a different one for each color, which means you don't have to throw out
the unused ink in a tank just because you've used up all the yellow.
Three-color ink jets may soon disappear as the prices
for four-color ink jets continue to drop. But you can still find a few
representatives of this vanishing breed. Three-color ink jets are
essentially the same as low-end four-color models, except that they
can't hold both a tricolor cartridge and a black-ink cartridge (the
fourth color) at the same time. Instead, you have to switch the
cartridge to change between color and monochrome printing. Given the
current prices of four-color ink jets, there's almost no reason to get a
three-color ink jet.
The photo ink jet category isn't as clear-cut as the
other two. Many four-color ink jets print photos at almost true
photographic quality. And some printers that are labeled "photo ink
jets" are simply four-color printers with one or two photo-friendly
features added, such as the ability to plug in a digital camera directly
to print photos. (See the sidebar
"Photo
Printers" for more on photography-related
features.)
No matter what features a printer has, however,
four-color printers are hampered by their gamut, or the range of colors
they can produce. A printer's gamut depends on the inks used. Most photo
ink jet printers expand their gamuts by using additional ink colors,
usually light cyan and light magenta. And for most of these printers,
photographic output is almost or completely indistinguishable from
processed prints. Unfortunately, many photo ink jets are uncomfortably
slow when printing text, so check out a photo printer's text speed
before considering it as your only printer.
Laser Printers
A true laser printer uses a photosensitive drum or belt that picks up an
electrostatic charge wherever the laser beam hits it. The charged areas
then pick up toner and transfer the toner to paper. When most people
refer to laser printers, however, they actually mean laser-class
printers; some of the subcategories within laser printers use notably
different technologies. What laser printers have in common is that even
the slowest models print faster than almost any ink jet printer. As a
rule, they also produce crisper lines and edges for text and graphics
than do ink jets.
Laser printers fall into four categories: monochrome,
four-pass color, single-pass color, and solid ink. The most popular
category of laser-class printers, monochrome lasers, offer a level of
crispness for text and lines that ink jet printers can't match without
slowing to a crawl. It's getting harder to find a monochrome laser with
a speed of less than 12 pages per minute (ppm). This category also
includes LED and LCD printers. All three use light to draw the image of
a page on a photosensitive drum or belt. The defining difference lies in
the light source: laser, LED, or LCD.
Color laser printers—whether four pass or single
pass—are for people who want the speed and text quality of a monochrome
laser but need color, too. The best color lasers even print photographs
as well as many ink jets, though no color laser that we've seen can
match the true photo quality of the best photo ink jets.
Four-pass color lasers take at least four times as
long to print in color as in black and white. A single laser beam draws
a separate image for each of the four ink colors (cyan, magenta, yellow,
and black), with the paper requiring a separate pass through the printer
for each image. This four-pass design is now limited to older models and
inexpensive low-end ones.
Single-pass color lasers are the standard today. Built
around four internal lasers, this kind of printer draws images for all
four colors at the same time. This lets it print all four images on a
page with a single pass, so the speed for color printing is the same as
for monochrome.
Keep in mind that with any color printer, you're
basically printing four images—one for each color—which must be aligned,
or registered. With single-pass lasers and LED printers, if the four
print images don't line up properly the output displays faulty
registration, causing blurry photos or visible gaps between sections of
a pie chart. Misregistration is generally more of a problem with color
LED printers than with color lasers.
Solid-ink printers start with a block of ink—usually
wax or resin—which they melt and then spray either directly on a page or
on a drum that rolls against one, as in an offset printing press. The
drum approach tends to show better results, because it offers print
speeds and output quality similar to a color laser's and produces more
consistent color. A disadvantage is that the ink doesn't slide well over
glass, which can cause paper jams in some office copiers.
Multifunction Printers
No matter what printer category you're interested in, you must also
choose between a standalone printer and an all-in-one (AIO) device—the
latest term for what is more commonly called a multifunction printer (MFP)
or multifunction device.
At minimum, an MFP combines a printer and scanner to
function as a printer, scanner, and copier. Most MFPs also have fax
capability, either via software that lets you use your computer's fax
modem or via built-in modems, letting you send faxes even when your
computer is off. Some include document feeders as well, making it easier
to scan and fax multipage documents.
The biggest argument against MFPs used to be that they
made serious compromises in one or more functions. This is no longer the
case, which is one reason they are becoming increasingly popular. The
current MFPs combine high-quality scanners with the same engines you'll
find in standalone printers. And they cost less than buying separate
components. But you may not be able to find the exact mix of printer,
scanner, copier, and fax features you want.
The tighter
you are on desktop space and budget, the more seriously you should
consider an MFP. The more particular you are in choosing a printer,
scanner, copier, and fax—with specific features for each—the less likely
you are to find an MFP that meets your needs.